H. D. Carlton and her pitch-black erotic mystery novel Haunting Adeline will forever be a pillar of dark romance history. Sure, its a little tropey—but it built the foundation for many of these tropes. H. D. Carlton is the type of dark romance storyteller that will be remembered for not being afraid to “go there,” and empowering a generation of authors to follow suit. I read everything she puts out, and am constantly looking for books that reach that Haunting Adeline high; here is how I would rank every H. D. Carlton book from worst to best (and why).
Related Read: Dark romance is a rebellion.
Does It Hurt? is a standalone dark romance that swaps the stalker-in-the-shadows setup for something weirder and honestly more unhinged: a shipwreck, a decrepit lighthouse, a genuinely creepy old man, and two people who are equally furious at and obsessed with each other. Sawyer is a identity thief on the run; Enzo is a shark biologist with mommy issues and a grudge (she stole his identity, to be fair).
The enemies-to-lovers tension is thick, the horror elements are legitimately disturbing, and the spice is turned all the way up. It’s less emotionally devastating than the Cat and Mouse duet and more of a thriller-flavored slow burn with a gothic setting that does a lot of heavy lifting. If you want your dark romance with a side of “what is even happening right now,” this one delivers.
Personally, I found the twists a bit too predictable and wished the eerie mysteries would have gotten more page space.
Where’s Molly? is a spinoff novella about “the girl from the diary.” Molly’s backstory is every bit as heartbreaking as you feared, but the book earns its lighter tone by leaning into the sweetness of what comes after survival rather than wallowing in the darkness itself (the trauma is largely off-page).
Cage, her obsessive and oddly wholesome MMC, is a genuinely fun deviation from the brooding antihero mold; this man will plan a movie night, bring flowers, and rub your feet while also being completely unhinged about you, which is honestly a compelling combination. It’s shorter and softer than the duet, functioning more as a satisfying epilogue to Molly’s arc than a full standalone story. Read the Cat and Mouse duet first; this one is a reward for people who made it through.
I honestly didn’t remember “Molly” from “the diary” but, hey, I’ll read anything H.D Carlton puts out. It wasn’t a side story I was seeking out, though.
Phantom is a prequel set in 1940s Seattle that finally answers the question the Cat and Mouse duet planted in your head: who was Gigi, and what actually happened between her and the man watching from the trees? Genevieve Parsons is a sharp, ahead-of-her-time woman trapped in a crumbling marriage to a gambling addict; Ronaldo is a mob consigliere with one eye, a lot of feelings, and absolutely no intention of staying out of her window view.
The historical setting is a genuinely fun change of pace (1940s gothic mafia romance is a sentence that should not work as well as it does), and the romance itself is softer and more tender than the rest of this catalog: less obsession spiral, more slow-burning forbidden love affair between two people who make each other feel like the first real thing. Read the Cat and Mouse duet first; the emotional weight of this one lands completely differently when you already know how the story ends.
I thought Gigi’s story was perfectly encapsulated in the diary segments from Haunting Adeline. The book was fine, but I would have preferred to leave it as it was. Not everything needs a sequel/prequel.
Satan’s Affair is a prequel novella set inside a traveling Halloween carnival where the star attraction is Sibby: a delightfully unhinged woman who uses the haunted house to quietly execute people she deems irredeemably evil, with the help of her five devoted henchmen. It is gory, weird, and genuinely unlike anything else in this universe (or possibly any universe).
Think less slow-burn romance and more “what if a girlboss ran a murder carnival,” with a reverse harem situation and a plot twist at the end that recontextualizes everything in a satisfying way. It’s not the strongest entry point and the writing is rougher than the duet, but Sibby herself is an absolute force of chaos who makes the whole thing worth it. Read it before the Cat and Mouse duet; you’ll appreciate her cameo a lot more with the full context.
Gore heavy, tons of fun, not for everyone…but it was for me. Sibby is a lot of fun; I was glad to have her back.
Adeline Reilly is a successful author who just inherited a gothic Victorian mansion from her grandmother (complete with diaries, ghost sightings, and a 75-year-old unsolved murder to unravel). Zade Meadows is a wealthy vigilante hacker who runs a secret operation taking down human trafficking rings, and who absolutely, unhinged-ly, cannot stop thinking about Adeline from the moment he spots her at a book signing.
Haunting Adeline is a stalker dark romance that is equal parts murder mystery and spicy obsession spiral, and it has absolutely no business being this good. The dual POV pulls you so deep into both characters that you start to understand Zade’s brand of “this is clearly wrong” logic, and worse, you start rooting for him anyway. Read the trigger warnings, clear your schedule, and maybe don’t make eye contact with your window at night.
I know it’s become kind of “cool” to hate on this book, but I have nothing for love for one of my very first trigger warning dark romance reads. The mystery novel + brutal eroticism one-two punch is a high I have been chasing in every book since.
Hunting Adeline picks up immediately where the first book left off, and it does not ease you in gently. This is the darker, heavier, more gut-wrenching half of the duet (and the first one was not exactly a spa day), so check those trigger warnings carefully before diving in.
What makes this sequel stand out is that it doesn’t skip the hard parts: the trauma, the aftermath, the slow and painful climb back to yourself. Adeline’s character arc is the real centerpiece here, and watching her go from surviving to something fiercer is genuinely earned. Zade remains the unhinged, obsessive, oddly romantic force of nature you fell for in book one; just more so, turned all the way up, fully unhinged and fully devoted.
My fondness for the Adeline books holds strong, and I genuinely believe the sequel is even better than the first. It’s one of the few cliffhanger titles that made me think: Oh, that break paid off.
My Dreadful Darling is the first book in a new duet and it is being received as a serious contender for the best thing in this catalog (high bar, considering the competition). Reverie is the daughter of a convicted serial killer; Dread is the son of his most famous victim; and they have been forced into the same university where Dread has spent four years making her life systematically miserable as a form of grief-fueled revenge.
It is a bully romance that earns the label: creative, escalating, and genuinely mean in ways the genre usually just gestures at. The spice is reportedly the most intense entry in this catalog yet (which is also a high bar), the mystery threading through the plot is legitimately gripping, and the enemies-to-lovers slowburn has readers already debating whether Dread might dethrone Zade. Check the trigger warnings, note that it ends on a cliffhanger, and enjoy my favorite H.D Carlton book to date.
I like My Dreadful Darling so far and think the series could easily dethrone Adeline for me if the next book(s) hold up.
Shallow River is the outlier in this catalog: less stalker fantasy, more gut-punch reality check. River escaped a brutal childhood in Shallow Hill only to find herself tangled up with Ryan, a charming and deeply dangerous man whose abuse escalates in ways that are uncomfortably true to life. This is not the fun, morally flexible dark romance of the Cat and Mouse duet; this is the kind of dark that sits with you, because it mirrors something real.
Mako (Ryan’s estranged brother, and the MMC worth rooting for) is a genuinely good man in a lineup that doesn’t produce many of those, and River herself is the kind of heroine who doesn’t need rescuing so much as she needs room to do what she’s already capable of. Consider this one the most intense entry point in the catalog, and treat the trigger warnings like a contract: read them, take them seriously, and only proceed if you’re in a good headspace for it.
H.D Carlton hits her stride with Shallow River. It’s brutal, honest, captivating, devastating, poetic, and gut-wrenching all at once.
Turn the Page…
Do you agree with my rankings? Let me know in the comments.
You Might Also Like: The Best Masked Men Dark Romance Books to Read Right Now